Subject: Oncor Reacts to Smart Meter Anger
From: "Eric Schwerin" <[email-masked]>
To: "Hunter Biden" <[email-masked]>, <[email-masked]>
Date: Tue, 16 Mar 2010 14:58:37 -0400

Oncor Reacts to Smart Meter Anger

Oncor faces customer backlash over smart meters and skyrocketing electric
bills.

[image:
http://www.greentechmedia.com/content/images/articles/smart-meter.jpg]

Blame it on the weather, again.

Oncor <http://oncor.com/> is the latest company facing a media relations
firestorm over customer reports that their smart meters are overcharging for
electricity. The Texas Public Utilities Commission has called for an
independent verification of the meters, despite the fact that Oncor said
that nearly all of the complaints, which have jumped about 10-fold since a
year ago, can be explained by the unusually cold winter in Texas. The
testing is expected to begin in the next few weeks.

In the meantime, not all customers are buying the weather explanation. Ree
Wattner of Dallas, TX, received her smart meter in late November and saw her
bill nearly triple from about 1,500 kWh to about 4,400 kWh.

“That’s an incredible increase,” she said, “and that was after the smart
meter was put in.” Wattner is one of the co-founders of Smart UR Citizens, a
consumer group that feels the higher rates are being caused by the smart
meters.

Oncor said that the increase in complaints isn’t just from the smart meter
customers, which currently number about 760,000. Company spokesman Chris
Schein said three-quarters of the 4,000 calls they’re fielding monthly are
folks with traditional meters that have also seen huge increases due to the
weather. He also noted that last year was a particularly mild winter, and so
customers are probably seeing an even bigger jump than usual in their kWh
increase from the previous winter.

The Texas PUC isn’t buying the weather argument all together. The Commission
responded to requests from Texas State Senator Troy Fraser and consumers for
independent verification.

“We’re enthusiastically supporting the testing program so that we can
eliminate any seeds of doubt about the accuracy of these meters in
consumers’ minds. Once we get these concerns behind us, all of us can get
focused on the real cause of the high bills and help consumers address
that,” Bob Shapard, Oncor Chairman and CEO, said in a statement.

It seems as though Oncor didn’t learn much from Pacific Gas & Electric’s
experience with disgruntled
customers<http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/pges-bakersfield-problem-getting-the-customer-on-board/>.
Some Texans are using the lawsuit against PG&E in California as fodder for
the conflict with Oncor, since both PG&E and Oncor use smart meters from
Landis+Gyr. Landis+Gyr, however, denies that there is any problem with its
meters, and insists that, as one of the leaders in smart meters, it is part
of the solution, not part of the problem.

"News reports questioning the billing accuracy of the Landis+Gyr smart
meters being deployed by Oncor are wrong and misleading," said Stan March,
senior vice president of corporate communications at Landis+Gyr. "In fact,
Oncor has repeatedly said that there is nothing wrong with Landis+Gyr smart
meters. That should not come as a surprise. Landis+Gyr is the global leader
in electricity metering, having successfully delivered millions of smart
meters around the world."

The real cause of your high bill? Well, if you ask Oncor, it’s probably your
incredibly inefficient heating system. Schein was quick to point out that
the greatest percentage of calls comes from homes with electric strip
heating or electric space heaters. Wattner, however, has gas heat, and said
she has still seen her bill double (though she admitted to having a few
space heaters around). Oncor said it has not found a single smart meter yet
that is not measuring accurately.

But that’s not entirely true.  Up to 1 percent of smart meters may have an
installation error, according to Oncor. If those numbers are accurate, that
means between 3,800 and 7,600 people are seeing sky-high bills that are due
to human error. Although those smart meters can be fixed, that’s still a lot
of angry people.

Wattner is still not convinced that weather and human error are enough to
explain the bills and her group will begin canvassing neighborhoods tonight
to see who else is angry about their smart meters. “The fact that it’s human
error is propaganda,” she said.

While Oncor plugs along with its side-by-side meter comparison, it looks as
though customers are just getting more irate. Even if Oncor doesn’t uncover
a single inaccurate smart meter (which it said it had not found from
preliminary data of the most recent side-by-side comparison), it will
definitely still have to contend with a lack of consumer confidence that
could mar the rollout of the rest of the company's smart meters.

Eric D. Schwerin

Rosemont Seneca Partners, LLC

1010 Wisconsin Ave., NW

Suite 705

Washington, DC 20007

(202) 333-1880

[email-masked] <[email-masked]>

*P** **Consider the environment before printing this email.**