Subject: Export coal: our power gift to Asia - Australian
From: "Michael Andrews" <[email-masked]>
To: "Hunter Biden" <[email-masked]>, "Curtis Hastings" <[email-masked]>, "Devon Archer" <[email-masked]>, "Eric Schwerin" <[email-masked]>, "Neil Callahan" <[email-masked]>
Date: Thu, 4 Nov 2010 12:19:58 -0400

Export coal: our power gift to Asia
Natasha Bita and Annabel Hepworth From:The Australian November 05,  
2010 12:00AM
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Print
Email
Share

SOUTH Korea and Taiwan are managing to produce cheaper power than  
Australia, even though they have to ship the Australian coal that  
fires their furnaces.

In self-sufficient Australia, households are paying one-third more for  
electricity than those in Taiwan and South Korea - two of the biggest  
buyers of Australian coal.

Residential power prices in Australia have surged 12.4 per cent in the  
past year, four times the rate of inflation.

Australia is now paying more for power than some of the countries to  
which it ships its coal, who also happen to be trade competitors.

Local households paid 14.3c for every kilowatt hour of residential  
power, while Asian households paid 10.6c, based on the most recent  
2008 data provided by the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and  
Resource Economics.

Industrialists yesterday declared that Australia's surging power  
prices could rob the manufacturing and mining sectors of their  
competitive edge.

Related Coverage
HIGH DEMAND: Popular solar grants risk bubble
BOOM: Installers make hay while the sun shines
FEATURE: Solar panels at boiling point
Surge in price of electricityThe Australian, 20 Oct 2010
'Climate push fuels cost hikes' The Australian, 12 Oct 2010
NSW at mercy of utility bill rip-off Daily Telegraph, 9 Oct 2010
Households brace for stinging bill blowout The Australian, 6 Oct 2010
Struggling families Herald Sun, 6 Oct 2010

Ray Horsburgh, a former chief executive of the Smorgon Steel Group who  
now sits on several boards, including that of building materials  
company CSR, warned of the dangers of rising electricity costs.

The risk was that, eventually, locally produced aluminium, steel and  
other metals "just won't be competitive" with ingots or slab imported  
from China.

"It's very important in any smelting industry in Australia, steel, any  
of the metals that are smelted, power becomes a competitive factor,"  
Mr Horsburgh said.

"They are not high-labour content plants, these smelters, so labour is  
not such an important cost component; power becomes the most important  
cost."

Asciano chairman Malcolm Broomhead, who is a BHP Billiton board  
member, predicted that power prices would soar as Australia put a  
price on carbon.

"That's the price of clean energy," he said yesterday.

"The days of cheap power are behind us. That's going to be an issue  
for the community generally to come to grips with."

While Australian households paid relatively more for their electricity  
than their Asian counterparts, industrial customers paid similar  
amounts for power: 8.4c in Australia, 7c in Korea and 8.2c in Taiwan.

But in Japan, the biggest buyer of Australian coal, industrial power  
prices were double Australia's at 14.3c, with households paying 21c.

Industry analyst Ben Freund, the chief executive of energy price  
comparison website GoSwitch, said of Japan: "They have to import the  
fuel and transport it from Australia. They are ultimately paying a lot  
more for their fuel than we are, but they don't impose artificial  
costs on their consumers like we do.

"They look upon the power sector as meeting the needs of the economy  
at a low price. But in Australia, the energy sector has become  
something of a plaything for politicians."

The Energy Users Association of Australia yesterday claimed power  
prices were on track to double within five years and triple within a  
decade as utilities spent billions of dollars on infrastructure, and  
the federal government forced them to source one-fifth of their  
supplies from renewable energy by 2020.

EUAA executive director Roman Domanski said: "Low power prices have  
been a real bonus for the Australian economy and community, but that  
is rapidly starting to change.

"Power prices are fast getting out of control and we will find  
ourselves losing competitiveness - a number of companies could close  
down and move offshore."

Mr Freund said Australia had not built any new coal-fired power  
stations for two decades, despite surging demand from a growing  
population fond of power-hungry air-conditioning, clothes dryers and  
flat-screen TVs.

"Demand for power has been increasing exponentially but we haven't  
built any of those coal-fired power stations to support the grid," Mr  
Freund said.

"If demand is increasing, we should just be producing more of it;  
supply should meet demand as it does for any other commodity and we  
shouldn't be seeing these sorts of skyrocketing prices."

The federal government's Australian Energy Regulator, which regulates  
the nation's wholesale electricity market, warned this week that  
consumers faced blackouts unless they paid more for power.

AER chairman Andrew Reeves said yesterday he could not comment on the  
lower power prices in South Korea and Taiwan as he was not familiar  
with their industry structures.

But in an interview with The Australian, he likened Australia's  
electricity transmission network to a run-down car.

He said electricity infrastructure built in the 1960s and 70s required  
costly upgrades to cope with the surge in demand.

"The big drivers (of higher bills) are replacing infrastructure built  
in the 1960s and 70s and the need to expand the network, because  
customers are using more air-conditioners and bigger appliances," he  
said.

"The network hasn't been designed to cope with it.

"And all the (electricity) businesses are at that phase in the  
business cycle where they need substantial reinvestment.

"It's a bit like your car - once it gets to 15 years old you've really  
got to replace it."

Cheap coal provides three-quarters of Australia's power supplies,  
although renewable energy from solar and wind power has been growing  
at a rate of 10 per cent a year over the past decade.

Half of South Korea's power comes from coal.

Coal is Australia's largest commodity export, supplying 18 per cent of  
the thermal coal trade and earning $55 billion in 2008-09.

Most is destined for power plants in Japan, South Korea and Taiwan for  
electricity generation.

Pri